Commissioner says PUC couldn't rule on Black Hills Power's wind farm request

Mike and Eileen Miller's ranch, which is located northwest of Belle Fourche, was proposed as the site of a Black Hills Power wind farm. BHP withdrew its proposal after the state Public Utilities Commission refused to rule on the company's request to have it declared "reasonable and cost-effective" under the state's renewable energy goals. (Ryan Soderlin/Journal staff)

Public Utilities Commissioner Gary Hanson said Tuesday that while he supported a proposed Black Hills Power wind farm, he maintained the commission’s unanimous position that it does not have the statutory authority to make a formal determination about the project before it is built.

Black Hills Power announced Monday that it has shelved plans for what would have been the first commercial wind farm West River, a $38 million project 8 miles north of Belle Fourche.

The utility said the project was too risky without a PUC ruling that the wind farm was “reasonable and cost effective” under the state law governing South Dakota’s renewable energy goal.

“Ultimately, they wanted 100 percent assurance, (which) we simply were not able to give them without going through the rate process,” Hanson said of a process that can’t occur until a wind farm is built and a rate hike is requested by the utility.

Black Hills Power said the effect on a customer’s bill would be about a 1.5 percent increase if the company did eventually raise rates to cover its costs.

Hanson said he was prepared to vote against the PUC staff’s recommendation on the matter, saying he thought the wind farm proposal had a lot of advantages.

The project would have included between seven and 12 turbines, each about 250 feet tall, and would have provided 20 megawatts of electricity, enough to power about 8,500 homes for a year, with the potential to generate up to 50 megawatts.

“The cost of power was lower than most I’ve seen,” Hanson said. “It was an economical and reasonable opportunity. It looked like it would be a pretty darn good project. I anticipated supporting it and thought that it would go through the process without a hitch like wind projects do.”

But he changed his mind after studying the staff’s documentation supporting its decision.

“It became clearer and clearer that the commission was not legally permitted to rule in Black Hills’ favor,” Hanson said.

Hanson said he expects lawmakers will take up the issue in next year’s Legislative session. He said they should study whether the law contains an unnecessary disincentive.

Cost Of Wind Energy - News


Commissioner says PUC couldn't rule on Black Hills Power's wind farm request
Commissioner says PUC couldn't rule on Black Hills Power's wind farm request

The utility said the project was too risky without a PUC ruling that the wind farm was “reasonable and cost effective” under the state law governing South Dakota's renewable energy goal. “Ultimately, they wanted 100 percent assurance, (which) we simply



Green taxes hit wind turbine makers
Green taxes hit wind turbine makers

One major construction company is now finding it will soon cost less to import its cement from Spain than to produce it at its UK plant. Yet Tata makes the steel that goes into the turbines. Ineos makes the lubrication that helps the blades turn.



MORNING ROUNDUP: Maine Official Backtracks, Says Administration Supports ...
MORNING ROUNDUP: Maine Official Backtracks, Says Administration Supports ...

The senior energy adviser to Maine Gov. Paul LePage said yesterday that his previous concerns about the cost of offshore wind power might have been unjustified, the Maine Public Broadcasting Network reported. “I think there was a little bit of a



Solar v. wind: which gets more government love?
Solar v. wind: which gets more government love?

The cash grant program, run by the US Department of Treasury, doled out large awards going quickly to big wind farm projects in the early days of the program's deployment. Energy giant Iberdrola was a big beneficiary. The story is different with the



Fire Island wind farm finds customer
Fire Island wind farm finds customer

The proposed Fire Island wind farm in Anchorage is moving closer to reality under a deal with Chugach Electric Association that would lock in the price of power for the next 25 years. The Chugach board of directors is expected to approve a power




How much would it cost me to install a complete wind turbine ...

How much would it cost me to install a complete wind turbine system?

With my electricity bill as high as it is, I’m considering going off of city power and installing a wind turbine system that can power my whole house. I live in the state of Oregon. Can someone give me a ball park cost for such an endeavour and what kind of performance I could expect? Thanks.

A few years ago a coworker looked into this because they found out after they moved a mobile home onto their property that it was going to cost about $10,000 to have electric brought in. The wind turbine setup was also about the same price. Remember that your generator needs to be larger than your average load to charge batteries for when the wind does not blow. I am in Oklahoma where we have some of the best conditions for wind generation and still would need considerable storage.


Twitter

Project SEDA GE prepared to join energy 'megatrend' cost of wind power is falling, making it a long-te… (cont)


Charles Donnelly GE prepared to join energy 'megatrend': The levelised cost of onshore wind was around nine to 10 US cents per ki...


Ian Young Radio interview with Prof of Energy Conversion this morning. energy from wind farms cost twice as much as that from Nuclear. Interesting huh


Saad Imran there are better alternatives to wind energy. Waste of tons of space, high cost, and limited energy.


siemensindia Wind power to save $34.2 bn of fuel cost in 2015 , , , , ,


Cost Of Wind Energy - Bookshelf

Wind Energy Explained, Theory, Design and Application

Wind Energy Explained, Theory, Design and Application

Estimates of the capital costs and O&M costs of a wind energy system, ... 11.3 Capital Costs of Wind Energy Systems 11.3.1 General Considerations The ...

Wind energy comes of age

Wind energy comes of age

7 Wind Energy's Declining Costs It started in 1989 when John Schaefer published a short article in the Electric Power Research Institute's technical journal ...

Renewable energy annual 1995

Renewable energy annual 1995

The cost of wind energy, estimated at 50 cents per kilowatthour in 1980, dropped to a range of 5 to 7 cents per kilowatthour by the end of 1993.96 Today, ...

Wind energy-- the facts, a guide to the technology, economics and future of wind power

Wind energy-- the facts, a guide to the technology, economics and future of wind power

Figure VI.4.4: Avoided fuel cost from wind energy, 2000–2030 (IEA fuel 5 0 2000 ... Had the €/$ exchange rate been 1, wind energy's avoided fuel cost would ...

1999 European Wind Energy Conference, wind energy for the next millennium : proceedings of the European Wind Energy Conference, Nice, France, 1-5 March 1999

1999 European Wind Energy Conference, wind energy for the next millennium : proceedings of the European Wind Energy Conference, Nice, France, 1-5 March 1999

A Swedish study has analysed the development of the ex factory cost of wind turbines based on the price per rated generator capacity (DKK/kW). ...

Information Source Directory


Wind power - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Wind power is the conversion of wind energy into a useful form of energy, such as using ... Wind Energy Association report gives an average generation cost of ...

Wind
Wind is a proven, cost-effective, and environmentally attractive source of power. ... Energy produced at the New Mexico Wind Energy Center will replace an equivalent amount of ...

Cost of Wind Energy - Wind Energy Cost - Wind Power for Homes
There is a growing interest lately in the cost of wind energy compared to standard on-the-grid power. Global climate change, along with an increased awareness and ...

Wind Energy Cost-Wind Energy Cost Manufacturers, Suppliers ...
Choose Quality Wind Energy Cost Manufacturers, Suppliers, Exporters at Alibaba.com. ... of wind,energy saving and cost saving,great function of exhaust... Power Source: wind ...

How Wind Energy Works | Union of Concerned Scientists
Information on renewable energy, including wind and solar power; nuclear-power safety issues and work of the Union of Concerned Scientists to switch America to ...